Honey Peanut Butter Fudge or Caramel

I regularly (honestly, at least once a week) make a batch of fudge. I eat it all myself. It is high in sugar and wonderful and I have a sweet tooth and I do not watch my diet (thus endeth the confession part of this post). Now that I have bees and lots of honey, I thought maybe my fudge addiction could be made better (in what sense of the word I’m not sure) with honey.

So I substituted 1/2 of the sugar with honey and gave it a try. The result is a much creamier and softer concoction than I’m used to (I make my fudge very hard, much more than any I’ve ever bought at a store). The first batch of honey fudge tasted just like the gooey caramel you get in a Mars Bar. The 2nd batch (I cooked it a little longer) was firmer, more like a piece of caramel you can buy wrapped in clear plastic. It’s different than my normal fudge in texture and in taste. Different, not worse or better. Another addiction to add to my list.

Here’s my honey peanut butter fudge recipe – it couldn’t be simpler and takes about 10 minutes to make:

IMG_0250IMG_0259IMG_0261IMG_02631) Put into a deep pot:

– 1 cup milk
– 1 cup sugar
– 1 cup honey (or 2 cups sugar and no honey for my normal recipe)
– 1/2 teaspoon salt
– 1 Tablespoon of cocoa powder

2) Place the pot on a medium heat (I use the smallest burner on my gas stove and turn it to high – I’m not a patient cook) and let it simmer.

3) Fudge (and other sugary milky sweets) will boil up really high in the pan than sink down. When it sinks down, it’s starting to get close to being ready.

4) Cook until soft ball stage (I imagine it’s easy to find out what temp that is). You can determine soft ball stage by dropping a bit of the cooking fudge into a glass of cold water. If you can reach in and pick it out as a single soft ball, it’s done. If it disintegrates, keep cooking. If it cracks, you’ve made honey brittle.

5) Turn off stove and add a tablespoon of butter and 2 tablespoons of peanut butter to the fudge. Stir like mad until both melt.

6) Move the pot to a water bath (standing water in the bottom of your sink) and stir like mad some more until the fudge just starts to thicken.

7) Pour into a greased heat-proof tray.

8) Let stand to cool.

Whether you spoon it out in gooey dollops, slice off beautiful squares or break your fudge into hard pieces (depending on how firm your batch turns out) the taste is sweet and creamy and just plain old Nirvana.


About Laura Rittenhouse

I'm an American-Australian author, gardener and traveller. Go to my writing website: www.laurarittenhouse.com for more. If you're trying to find my gardening blog, it's here.
This entry was posted in Recipe and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

25 Responses to Honey Peanut Butter Fudge or Caramel

  1. I wish I could live at your house… I’m such a big chocaholic that enjoying a weekly batch of fudge sounds like heaven!

  2. oh gosh that sounds too naughty (and yummy) for words….

  3. Glenn Rittenhouse says:

    Sounds delicious. Wish we lived closer.

    • Oh no, what an influence we’d be on each other. We’d both be in full dentures because our poor teeth wouldn’t stand a chance. We just might never leave the house because we’d be too busy eeating sweets all day.

  4. anamonreal19 says:

    Sounds delicious, will try it out!! My hubby loves chocolate.

  5. Oh how I WISH! I would love to make and eat that delicious looking fudge.
    But alas, I am a Coeliac and along with Coeliac disease often come diabetes and I am pre diabetes so am not supposed to have sugar. But then again, I am pre! Only pre!
    Mmmmmm, that fudge looks good.

  6. BTW, love the new header photo.

    • Thanks. I have a few I rotate between – honey if I’m posting about honey; garden snaps for garden posts; bee snaps for bee posts; chicken snaps – I have a LOT of chicken snaps 🙂 Of course if you don’t read the post on the day I put it out there the header doesn’t match, but I’ve decided variety is (on of) the spice of life.

  7. hmmmm, hmmmmm, hmmmm. how yummy! your neighbours and friends must love you sooo much, now you are adding fudge to your many yummy treats! Oh how I wish I could gobble it up! xxx

  8. Why don’t you way 50 million pounds (she says enviously, spitefully, with a raging sugar/choco jones)?!?!?

  9. Pingback: Carrot Cake Recipe | Laura Rittenhouse's Gardening Journal

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s